The Royal Commission circus has come to an end. Some good things will be achieved in cleaning up behaviors in the industry, yet with three volumes of findings, it seems that mortgage broking is one issue that remains misunderstood. Here are my thoughts on what’s missing.
In Australia, for some reason we expect insurance companies and banks to do the impossible and provide objective advice.
However, their first loyalty is always to maximise returns for their shareholders. A bank will always offer customers the highest interest rate and highest fees that they can get away with and still win the business — so why do we expect them to be different?
As much as they publicly pretend they don’t, banks really do need mortgage brokers.
Why? Because it’s a far cheaper and more efficient way for them to generate sales than to try and do it themselves. Sales generated through brokers avoids the huge cost of the team, advertising and resources needed to generate them. It’s therefore entirely reasonable that banks offer a discounted rate or pay a fee to a mortgage broker for generating the business.
Brokers who compare multiple lenders are the solution, not the problem.
A broker compares options across multiple lenders to secure competitive rates and fees – not just one bank’s product range. They’re ethically and legally obliged to put the customer’s interests first. The Productivity Commission gets it, both sides of politics get it, the public certainly gets it but unfortunately, the Royal Commission did not.
In my view, the Royal Commission outcomes need to include the following:
- Advice must put the customer first. Customers should seek advice from accountants, financial advisers and brokers who compare the market. They should stay away from service providers, banks and insurance companies with conflicting interests, who shouldn’t be allowed to provide advice in the first place.
- Advisors should be paid for the service they provide. Customers should have an option to elect for a bank or insurer to part pay some of the fees and have that cost incorporated as part of their finance transaction, or to pay the advisors directly themselves.
- Empower ASIC and the Ombudsman to take on the unconscionable behaviour demonstrated by the likes of AMP and CBA. Generational bad behaviour is entrenched within the big banks. This will keep happening unless major ethics and behaviour disruptors are introduced by boards to change the arrogant and outdated conduct. The regulators need to be empowered to fulfil their vital role.
- Mortgage aggregators must manage conflicts of interest transparently. A number of mortgage aggregators are owned by the major banks and, quite simply, this shouldn’t be allowed to happen. Mortgage brokers using bank-owned aggregators should vote with their feet and leave.
- Every mortgage broker and financial adviser needs to achieve the industry minimum standard. The majority of brokers always put their customers’ interests first. The few that don’t meet ongoing standards should exit the industry.
The other critical thing is that consumers need to accept that they are responsible for themselves and should not rely on ‘no cost’ advice from a bank or insurance company.
Now more than ever, it’s important to surround yourself with experienced, trusted accountants, brokers and advisors, both personally and professionally.
To discuss your personal or business finance needs with an experienced specialist, call Andrew Sutherland at Halidon Hill Finance on 03 7018 3270 or get in touch via email at andrew.sutherland@halidonhill.com.au.

Director
Profile: https://halidonhill.com.au/people/andrew-sutherland/
